You make cast after cast without a fish while the guy next to you hooks one after another. You’re using a pearl-colored crankbait. He’s using a pearl-colored crankbait. The difference? His crankbait has a pink strip on the belly, and yours does not. “Why!?!” you scream to the fish gods. The answer is simple: Fish are choosy, so you need to pick just the right fishing lure color to spark their appetite.

Learning to Choose the Right Lure Color

We look at a fish and see amazing colors and patterns. A fish looks at these colors and sees important messages about the edibility of its prey. Communicating the same message with an artificial lure is the only way to trick a fish to bite.

Designing colors and patterns for new fishing lures starts on the water. Professional anglers are vital to the process. Hobie pro and Bassmaster champion Mike Iaconelli has seen a lot of changes in lure color over his 20 years on the tournament trail.

Mike Iaconelli holds up three different color fishing lures
Mike Iaconelli holds three Rapala lures in different colors. | Feature photo: Courtesy of Rapala Lures

“I used to customize my own baits with markers and paint,” he remembers. “Now lures come out of the package even closer to the real thing.” Iaconelli’s DT Ink series crankbaits not only mimic color, but depth and sheen.

“Many baitfish have a purple tinge,” Iaconelli points out, “and each scale sparkles.” Rapala designed the Ink series with metallic sparkle paint to imitate the brilliance of fish scales under a wet surface.

Lure Makers Go Beyond Matching the Hatch

The same attention to detail goes into soft plastic lures. Dan Nussbaum at Z-Man explains that contrast can be an important factor in color design.

“Bait patterns vary from region to region, so we make colors that match a specific area,” he says. Perfectly matching the hatch isn’t always enough. “Sometimes contrast is more important than exact imitation,” he explains. That’s why wild colors like chartreuse and pink, called Electric Chicken, don’t imitate nature but still get bites.

“Most fish have a dark back and a lighter belly. Matching that contrast can draw the fish’s attention,” adds Nussbaum. Z-Man even hired a lure designer with an art degree to cook up new colors. “He uses color theory to help understand which pigments can be combined to achieve a desired look.”

It’s not just color and contrast, but perfectly matching the pattern on a baitfish. Stephen Browning, Bassmaster Elite Pro and LiveTarget lures guru points to subtle variations in lines, spots, blotches and speckles.

“Our Sunfish Hardbody comes in 14 variations that match regional differences in color and pattern,” says Browning. They break the patterns down to two sunfish subspecies: bluegill and pumpkinseed. “Bluegill have bars and pumpkinseeds have mottled spots,” he explains. Then, they go to the extent of matching the bright colors of a sunfish being driven to the surface by a predator. “We also have pattern variations for fish in tanic or clear water.”

Modify Your Lures for Just the Right Look

Even with the amazing attention to detail possible with modern lures, old tricks die hard. With all the colors and patterns available to pro angler Iaconelli, he still breaks out the permanent markers and lure paint once in a while. “I don’t want to be that guy not catching fish,” he laughs.

Mike Iaconelli holds three Rapala lures in different colors. | Feature photo: Courtesy of Rapala Lures

This article was first published in the Spring 2017 issue of Kayak Angler Magazine. Subscribe to Kayak Angler Magazine’s print and digital editions, or browse the archives.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here